| Player | Year |
| Quinn Hill | 2009 |
| Calvin Huggins | 2010 |
| Calvin Huggins | 2011 |
| Trevon Brown | 2012 |
| Conlan Beaver | 2013 |
| Jeremy Brown | 2014 |
| Conlan Beaver | 2015 |
| Louie Mihota | 2016 |
| Donavan Beaver | 2017 |
| Donavan Beaver | 2018 |
| Johnny Lagana | 2019 |
O Lineman Award
| Player | Year |
| Quinn Hill | 2009 |
| Calvin Huggins | 2010 |
| Calvin Huggins | 2011 |
| Trevon Brown | 2012 |
| Conlan Beaver | 2013 |
| Jeremy Brown | 2014 |
| Conlan Beaver | 2015 |
| Louie Mihota | 2016 |
| Donavan Beaver | 2017 |
| Donavan Beaver | 2018 |
| Johnny Lagana | 2019 |